It’s Not You, It’s Macro: When Economic Forces Overpower Fundamentals
You did the research. You believed in the management team. The earnings came in strong, revenue beat expectations, the guidance was decent, and still, your beloved stock fell like it was caught cheating in plain sight.
It’s not you.
It’s macro.
Welcome to one of the most maddening truths in investing: fundamentals don’t always matter. Not in the short term. Not when political winds scream louder than quarterly calls.
When the most powerful man in the world gets into a virtual fist to cuffs via text with the richest man in the world.
When the market is more worried about the Fed’s paralysis than a company’s balance sheet.
In times like this, earnings season becomes a sideshow. Solid businesses get punished. Meme’s rally. And rational investors feel like they’re stuck in a finance-themed episode of The Twilight Zone.
Meet the Macro Villains
To understand what’s really going on, you need to meet the cast of macroeconomic characters that periodically hijack the market and send your well-researched investments into a tailspin:
-
Interest Rates: When rates are caught in a state of paralysis, risk appetites fall. Great companies with promising long-term growth suddenly look less attractive when a 5% Treasury bond offers safety and yield. Even if the company is growing, its valuation gets hammered by rate expectations.
-
Whimsy: When the markets turn up or down at the whim of our Presidents next post on Truth Social
-
Labor: The jobs available in the market may start to fall like bowling pins at the local PBA event in town.
-
AI: The real adopters of AI are on both of our coasts. We may have to drag the mid-west and south into the new world order kicking and screaming.
-
Inflation: The silent portfolio killer. It eats margins, forces consumers to tighten wallets, and makes future earnings worth less in today’s dollars. Companies that sell non-essential goods or have tight pricing power feel the burn first.
-
Geopolitical Tension: War, tariffs, sanctions, and political instability make everyone nervous. It doesn’t matter that your AI company just signed a record number of contracts. If Russia is saber-rattling or China is slapping tariffs on chips, Wall Street hits the sell button.
-
The Fed: The real market mover. Forget earnings per share, these days, it’s all about how Jerome Powell pronounces “data dependent.” The Federal Reserve sets the tone. If investors hear “hawkish,” even the strongest stocks tremble. If they whisper “pivot,” the market dances.
Fundamentals Become Background Noise
In a rational world, fundamentals would be king. But investing isn’t just math, its emotion, perception, and timing. When macro takes the driver’s seat, even the most impressive earnings report is like yelling stock tips into a tornado.
It’s not that these companies stopped being great. It’s that greatness gets discounted when the whole market is bracing for a slowdown. Investors start asking, “How will they perform if things get worse?” That question can punish even the most consistent performers.
The Value of Macro Awareness
This isn’t a plea to abandon fundamental analysis. It’s a reminder that fundamentals alone aren’t enough. Macro forces are like the weather. You may build the sturdiest ship, but you still need to know when a hurricane is on the horizon.
In volatile macro environments, stock picking becomes risk management. You ask different questions:
-
How sensitive is this company to interest rates?
-
Is its pricing power strong enough to tariff costs or fight inflation?
-
Is its supply chain exposed to geopolitical risk?
-
What happens to their margins if oil hits $120 or down to $40?
These aren’t sexy questions. But they might save your bacon.
But Wait—Can’t I Just Ride It Out?
Long-term investors often say, “I’m not worried, I’m in it for the long haul.”
That’s the right attitude… if your time horizon can absorb short-term macro shocks. But if you need liquidity in the next year or two, it may not be wise to ignore macro entirely. That’s how you end up being forced to sell low.
Great investors know when to sit tight and when to shift. Sometimes, that means moving into more defensive sectors, trimming exposure to high-beta names, or holding more cash. Cash doesn’t compound, but it sure doesn’t lose 12% in a week either.
Emotional Detachment Is a Superpower
If you’re losing sleep over a company that you believe is great, take a breath. Remind yourself: it’s not you. It’s macro. That company didn’t suddenly forget how to innovate. But your stock is now playing in a different sandbox, and the bully in that sandbox is macroeconomic chaos.
This is why emotional detachment is critical. Don’t marry your stocks. Date them. Take them home to meet your spreadsheet, not your parents. If a stock can’t hold up under pressure, even if it’s due to outside factors, it might be time to part ways (or at least take a break).
When Macro Calms Down, Fundamentals Roar Again
Here’s the good news: this won’t last forever. Macro storms pass. And when they do, investors rush back to the stocks with strong fundamentals. The trick is having the capital and patience to still be standing when that rotation begins.
Sometimes that means holding through the storm. Sometimes that means trimming, raising cash, and buying back later. But always, it means understanding that short-term irrationality is part of the game.
Markets overcorrect. They overreact. And they always revert. The investor who accepts that, who can hold both macro awareness, and faith in fundamentals – is the one who survives.
So don’t take it personally. Your stock isn’t broken. Your thesis might still be valid. But the macro gods are throwing a tantrum, and everyone’s getting hit.
Just remember, it’s not you. It’s macro, the villain. The hero on the white horse is you and you can and will ride in and save the day.
PS. If you’re enjoying Stock Talk, would you mind taking a few seconds to forward it to a friend? It really helps grow the newsletter, (and helps more people find clarity, ideas, and better investing focus). Thx
Any content marked as Stock Talk may be paid for and are not endorsed or warranted by our staff or company. The content in our posts and notes is for educational or entertainment use and is not a substitute for professional advice or an offer to buy or sell any securities. Neither the publisher nor the editors are registered advisors, and we do not provide personalized counseling, only the teachings of what has worked for us and others. We can show you the means to do your own careful research, before you take your own action, based on anything you find in this content. By opening this email or clicking any links contained, you are reconfirming your opt-in status.
